Thomas Pringle TD

Pringle: Sea-fisheries bill ‘fatally flawed’

Pringle: Sea-fisheries bill ‘fatally flawed’

Independent TD for Donegal, Thomas Pringle, said he did not think there was a need for the proposed sea-fisheries bill, calling it “fatally flawed”.

What’s needed for a sustainable fishing industry, Deputy Pringle said, is a renegotiation of the Common Fisheries Policy.

Addressing the Dáil today (Wednesday) during the second stage debate of the Sea-Fisheries (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2021, Deputy Pringle said: “I think the bill is very fatally flawed, I believe, because it doesn’t provide proper outlets for people to go to court and having their case met there.” He said he expects the bill to end up in the courts if it is passed, as expected.

The bill will be difficult for masters of vessels to manage and he said fishermen will be looking to see the bill is implemented fairly.

Deputy Pringle said: “Because whether rightly or wrongly, the experience of many fishermen has been that the Government doesn’t work with them, but works against them in terms of how they go about their business.”

The deputy said: “Fishing no doubt is at a difficult stage and has been at a difficult stage with Brexit and with implementation of these penalty points. But fishing has always been at a difficult stage. Fishing has always been put on the back burner and left on the back burner.”

He said the only way for fishing to be put on a sustainable footing is through a complete review of the Common Fisheries Policy. He said wrongs were done even before Ireland joined the European Union, when the EU made the conservation of fishing stocks the sole responsibility of the European Commission.

Deputy Pringle said: “And why was that? It was because Europe was fully aware of what we were bringing to the table, and we weren’t.”

He said: “There has to be a recognition that the fishing industry has been shafted by Europe and by lack of Government response and support for it over the years. And it’s not any one government’s fault, it’s not any one individual’s fault, but it’s just the fault of the whole system and the whole system has worked against them.”

He said fishermen need a government to go to Europe and change the balance of how things are decided, rather than having the Government go to Brussels each year, “and come back with less again and dress it up as a success”.

If the CFP is not renegotiated, the fishing industry will continue to decline, “and it’s going to get into a situation where coastal communities won’t be able to survive,” he said.

Deputy Pringle said: “I think it’s symptomatic of the problems that are there that there’s been so much resistance to this legislation, but I think this legislation is flawed and I think it needs to be rehashed and dealt with again.”

He said: “We have an opportunity now, in relation to fishing, if we can do this over the next couple of years, we can work together to make this happen. Unfortunately, I don’t think the political will is there on the Government side to actually meet that.”